Growthbox (增长黑盒) and Emergine published their AI-search report on 31 July 2026. It analyses about 5,000 conversations across five models, with live web search enabled.
Chinese models cited third-party sources more often
Unit: %
Source: Growthbox × Emergine, 2026 report; sampled Chinese and overseas models
View as table
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Chinese models | 30.2% |
| Overseas models | 76.1% |
| Other sources, Chinese models | 69.8% |
| Other sources, overseas models | 23.9% |
The report calls overseas models “verifiers” (查证型) and Chinese models “inquirers” (打听型).
| Sources cited by AI | Chinese models | Overseas models |
|---|---|---|
| Official company sites | 30.2% | 76.1% |
| Other sources (video, media, encyclopedias, etc.) | 69.8% | 23.9% |
| Share of evidence from official sites when leading brands are mentioned | about 16–41% | about 61–85% |
Among non-company sources, Chinese models most often cited short video and social platforms, then trade media, news and press releases, reviews and rankings, and encyclopedias. The pattern is strongest in consumer categories: for leading consumer-electronics brands, only about 17% of the evidence came from official sites.
Doubao often cited Douyin in the sample
In the sampled conversations, Doubao cited Douyin more than any other source in most industries: about 66% of citations in consumer electronics and about 45% in sports and outdoor.
The key point is that AI cites the text it can extract from a video, not the visuals: titles, subtitles, and the specifications, steps and comparisons a creator says aloud. The report describes purely promotional creator videos as carrying “almost zero” usable information for AI.
Leading brands dominated sampled conversations
- The top brand in each industry appeared in 29.6% of conversations, and the top three together in 73.2%. Visibility in China is more concentrated among leaders than overseas.
Some brand assessments included qualifying statements
In Chinese models, 7.9% of brand assessments added a qualifying “but” statement. Of these statements, 62.9% pointed to a specific weakness; only 8.9% suggested another brand was better. Caveats were most common in hotels and travel (25.3%), enterprise services, sports and outdoor (15.0%) and education.
The report notes that, apart from enterprise services, these are all consumer categories where people buy an experience.
- Read the figures as results for this sample and period.
Method and coverage
They ran about 5,000 real AI search conversations, with live web search enabled, through three Chinese models (Doubao, DeepSeek, Tongyi Qianwen) and two English models (ChatGPT, Gemini), then coded every answer for the brands it named and the pages it cited.